Tylenol or Advil: What’s the Right Choice for You?
.png)
How They Work
Tylenol (acetaminophen) works on the brain’s pain and temperature centers. It’s great for reducing fever and easing general aches, like headaches or minor joint pains, however it doesn’t help with swelling.
Advil (ibuprofen), on the other hand, is part of a group called NSAIDs. It not only relieves pain and fever but also brings down inflammation. That makes it a better option for things like muscle injuries, joint pain, or menstrual cramps.
How Your Body Handles Them
Tylenol is gentler on the stomach, which is why it’s often recommended if you have ulcers or digestive issues. But it can hurt the liver if overused or taken with alcohol.
Advil can irritate the stomach and may affect blood pressure, kidneys, or heart—especially if taken frequently or in higher doses.
Special Circumstances When These Drugs Should Be Avoided
● Avoid Tylenol if you have severe liver disease or regularly consume alcohol.
● Avoid Advil if you have a history of stomach ulcers, kidney problems or heart disease, or if you had a recent open-heart surgery (CABG).
So, Which One’s Right for You?
● For fever or general pain: Tylenol is safe and effective.
● For pain with swelling (like a sprained ankle) or arthritis: Advil may be better.
When in doubt, always consult your primary care doctor, especially if you have chronic conditions like diabetes ,high blood pressure, kidney/liver problems or taking other medications. Always follow label instructions or your healthcare provider’s advice. Overuse of either medication can lead to serious health risks.
By Dr. Madhusmita Panda and Dr. Merina Das